Actual Police Officer here, verified in /r/protectandserve. There really is no magic answer. There is a ton of overlap between both groups and anyone who says they can consistently spot the difference is lying to you. I'd rather judge the situation based on the objective facts rather than my gut feeling.
22 COPS A LOT OF PEOPLE GET JUMPY AND TRY TO ‘ACT NORMAL’ AROUND LAW ENFORCEMENT HOW CAN YOU TELL GENUINELY SUSPICIOUS PEOPLE FROM SELFCONSCIOUS IDIOTS ACTING WEIRD
13 SOMETHING IN YOUR LIFE THAT IS SUPER FUCKING AWESOME
28 WORST EXAMPLE OF BAD PARENTING YOU'VE EVER WITNESSED
25 WHAT DID YOU DO SEXUALLY WITH YOUR FIRST PARTNER THAT YOU ONLY REALISED WASN'T NORMAL WHEN YOU GO...
17 ANYONE WHO WAS A KID GUEST ON MR ROGER'S SHOW IT REALLY LIKE ON THE SHOW AND DID YOU MAINTAIN AN...
29 IF CURIOUS GEORGE WAS INSTEAD NAMED SERIOUS GEORGE WHAT SORT OF PLOTLINES WOULD WE ENJOY
31 WHAT DO MOVIES NEVER GET RIGHT
32 WHAT COMPANY'S MOTTO WOULD DO TERRIBLY FOR ANOTHER COMPANY
21 THE MOST PORNO SITUATION YOUVE EVER HAD